The Role of Pre-Existing Conditions in a Personal Injury Case


When a pre-existing condition is involved, a personal injury case can become intricate and daunting. Numerous personal injury victims have pre-existing health conditions that can be exacerbated by an accident, which can create challenges in demonstrating the full extent of the damages incurred. This is where the proficiency of a medical malpractice lawyers are essential.

Pre-existing conditions are a significant factor in personal injury cases because they can affect the severity of an injury, the duration of recovery, and the overall outcome of the case. For example, if someone with a pre-existing back injury is involved in a car accident, it is challenging to determine the extent to which the accident worsened their condition. Similarly, if someone with a pre-existing heart condition suffers a slip and fall injury, it can be difficult to prove whether the fall caused the heart attack or whether the heart attack was already in progress before the fall.

To succeed in a personal injury case, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the defendant’s carelessness directly led to their injuries. However, if the plaintiff has a pre-existing condition, the defendant may claim that the accident did not cause the injuries and that they were a consequence of the existing condition. In such a scenario, it is critical for the plaintiff to seek guidance from a Brooklyn medical malpractice lawyer who has handled similar cases.

The role of a Brooklyn medical malpractice lawyer in a personal injury case involving pre-existing conditions is to help the plaintiff prove that their injuries were caused or worsened by the accident. The lawyers will work with medical professionals to assess the extent of the plaintiff’s injuries and how they relate to their pre-existing condition. The lawyer will also gather evidence, such as medical records and witness statements, to demonstrate the causal link between the accident and the plaintiff’s injuries.


In personal injury cases where pre-existing conditions are a factor, the “eggshell plaintiff” rule is a crucial consideration. This legal principle dictates that a defendant is responsible for all damages resulting from their negligence, regardless of any pre-existing conditions that may have made the plaintiff more vulnerable to injury. In essence, the defendant is obliged to accept the plaintiff as they are, with any pre-existing conditions that could have influenced the extent of their injuries. A Brooklyn medical malpractice attorney who is knowledgeable about this rule can leverage it to the plaintiff’s benefit. If you need legal representation for a personal injury case in Brooklyn, you can visit to learn more.

Another important factor in these cases is the issue of “aggravation versus acceleration.” Aggravation refers to a situation where the accident worsened the plaintiff’s pre-existing condition, while acceleration refers to a situation where the accident caused a new injury on top of the pre-existing condition. A Brooklyn medical malpractice lawyer will work to differentiate between these two scenarios, as they can have a significant impact on the plaintiff’s case.

The primary objective of a Brooklyn medical malpractice lawyer in a personal injury case with pre-existing conditions is to ensure that the plaintiff receives the appropriate compensation for their damages. The lawyer will leverage their expertise and experience to construct a compelling case, which includes gathering evidence, collaborating with healthcare professionals, and representing the plaintiff in court. With the right legal representation, even individuals with pre-existing conditions can receive the justice they are entitled to following an accident. Make sure to find the appropriate law firm or law firms by looking at their website for what cases they handle.